Which Finance Processes Should Change First with AI

Not all finance processes are equally ready for automation. Start with manual procure-to-pay and point-in-time processes for fastest impact.

TL;DR Summary

  • Procure-to-Pay First: Manual purchase requests, approvals, and invoice processing offer immediate wins
  • End-to-End Automation: Automate entire workflows, not just individual steps
  • Point-in-Time Elimination: Replace periodic batch processes with continuous real-time workflows
  • High-Volume Repetitive: Processes with many similar transactions benefit most from automation
  • Clear Rules: Well-defined decision logic automates easiest
  • Quick ROI: These processes deliver measurable time savings within 30-60 days

When finance teams start thinking about AI and automation, they often feel overwhelmed by the possibilities. Should we automate forecasting? Streamline the close? Enhance FP&A analysis?

As Jason Yocum advises, "Manual procure-to-pay and point-in-time processes should be automated end-to-end." This isn't arbitrary-these processes offer the clearest path to quick, measurable value.

Let's explore which finance processes you should automate first and why.

Priority #1: Procure-to-Pay Automation

The procure-to-pay (P2P) cycle-from purchase request through payment-remains largely manual in most organizations, despite being highly automatable.

Why P2P Should Be First

  • High Volume: Most organizations process hundreds or thousands of purchases monthly
  • Repetitive Nature: Same workflow repeats for each purchase with minor variations
  • Clear Rules: Approval hierarchies, spending limits, and vendor requirements are well-defined
  • Measurable Pain: Teams can quantify hours spent on manual PO creation and invoice processing
  • Cross-Functional Impact: Benefits extend beyond finance to procurement and operations

The Manual P2P Burden

In traditional P2P processes, finance teams manually:

  • Route purchase requests for approval
  • Create purchase orders from approved requests
  • Match invoices to POs and receiving documents (three-way match)
  • Resolve exceptions and discrepancies
  • Process approvals for payment
  • Execute payments and update systems

This consumes enormous time for work that follows predictable patterns.

What P2P Automation Delivers

  • Automated Routing: Requests flow to appropriate approvers based on rules
  • Intelligent Matching: AI matches invoices to POs even with minor discrepancies
  • Exception Handling: System flags issues requiring human attention, auto-processes routine items
  • Faster Processing: Purchase-to-payment cycle time drops from weeks to days
  • Better Compliance: Automated controls ensure policy adherence
  • Improved Visibility: Real-time tracking of spending commitments

Priority #2: Expense Management

Expense reporting represents another high-volume, rule-based process ripe for automation.

The Current State Pain

Employees waste hours:

  • Photographing receipts and uploading them
  • Manually categorizing expenses
  • Creating expense reports by matching receipts to credit card charges
  • Writing explanations for unusual expenses
  • Waiting for approval workflows

Finance teams waste hours:

  • Reviewing expense reports for policy compliance
  • Investigating questionable expenses
  • Requesting missing receipts or explanations
  • Processing reimbursements

What Automation Enables

  • Auto-Capture: OCR extracts data from receipt photos automatically
  • Smart Categorization: AI categorizes expenses based on merchant and past patterns
  • Auto-Matching: System matches receipts to credit card transactions
  • Policy Enforcement: Flags policy violations in real-time
  • Instant Reimbursement: Compliant expenses approved and paid automatically

Priority #3: Invoice Processing and AP Automation

Accounts payable represents one of finance's most time-consuming manual processes.

Manual AP Challenges

  • Invoices arrive in multiple formats (email, mail, portal)
  • Data entry errors create downstream problems
  • Matching invoices to POs requires manual review
  • Approval routing depends on manual email forwarding
  • Payment processing involves manual checks and data entry

Automated AP Benefits

  • Intelligent Capture: Extract invoice data regardless of format
  • Auto-Matching: Match invoices to POs and receiving documents
  • Smart Routing: Send invoices to correct approvers automatically
  • Payment Optimization: Schedule payments to optimize cash flow and capture discounts
  • Fraud Detection: AI identifies duplicate invoices and suspicious patterns

Priority #4: Eliminate Point-in-Time Processes

Many finance processes operate on periodic batches when they could be continuous.

Examples of Point-in-Time Inefficiency

  • Month-End Close: Waiting until month-end to reconcile accounts that could be continuously balanced
  • Periodic Reporting: Generating reports weekly when stakeholders need daily visibility
  • Batch Reconciliations: Reconciling transactions in batches instead of continuously
  • Quarterly Forecasts: Updating forecasts quarterly when business conditions change monthly

The Continuous Alternative

Modern systems enable continuous processing:

  • Continuous Close: Reconcile and close accounts as transactions occur
  • Real-Time Dashboards: Update key metrics continuously, not periodically
  • Rolling Forecasts: Maintain always-current forward-looking projections
  • Instant Reconciliation: Match and clear items as they happen

This shift from periodic to continuous reduces period-end crunch time and provides faster insights.

Selection Criteria: Which Processes to Automate First

Not every process should be automated immediately. Prioritize based on these factors:

1. Volume and Frequency

High-volume, frequently repeated processes offer the best ROI. A process that happens 500 times per month delivers more value from automation than one that happens 5 times.

2. Rule-Based Decisions

Processes governed by clear rules automate most easily. Subjective judgment-heavy processes are harder and should come later.

3. Manual Effort Required

Calculate current person-hours invested. Processes consuming significant manual effort justify automation investment.

4. Error Rates

Manual processes with high error rates benefit doubly from automation-time savings plus improved accuracy.

5. End-to-End Scope

Prefer automating entire workflows over individual steps. Partial automation often just moves bottlenecks rather than eliminating them.

6. Data Availability

Processes with digital, structured data automate easier than those requiring significant data capture or transformation.

Processes to Automate Later (Not First)

Some finance processes require more sophisticated automation and should wait until you've built expertise with simpler processes:

Complex Forecasting and Modeling

While AI can enhance forecasting, it requires significant domain expertise to implement well. Start with transactional automation first.

Accounting Policy Interpretation

Determining appropriate accounting treatment for complex transactions requires professional judgment that current AI can't fully replicate.

Strategic Planning and Analysis

These processes involve significant judgment and stakeholder collaboration. AI can support but shouldn't lead initially.

Relationship-Driven Processes

Board reporting, investor relations, and audit coordination depend heavily on human relationships and communication nuance.

How ChatFin Accelerates P2P and AP Automation

ChatFin's platform is specifically designed to automate the high-ROI processes finance teams should tackle first:

  • Intelligent Document Processing: Extract data from invoices, receipts, and purchase requests automatically
  • Smart Matching: Match documents even with discrepancies, flagging exceptions for review
  • Workflow Automation: Route approvals and process standard transactions without manual intervention
  • Continuous Processing: Eliminate batch processes in favor of real-time transaction handling
  • Exception Management: Surface items needing human attention while auto-processing routine transactions

Conclusion: Start with High-Volume, Rule-Based Processes

The path to successful finance automation isn't trying to automate everything at once. It's starting with processes that offer clear, measurable value: manual procure-to-pay cycles, expense management, invoice processing, and point-in-time workflows that could be continuous.

These processes are high-volume, rule-based, and consume significant manual effort-making them ideal automation candidates. Success here builds team confidence and expertise that enables tackling more complex automation later.

Start where the ROI is clearest. Build from there.